Roof Replacement Experts Serving the Finger Lakes, NY, Region

When it’s time to replace your roof, choose a roofing company that Finger Lakes, NY, homeowners trust for durable materials, expert installation, and local knowledge. Legacy Custom Contracting offers full roof replacements across the local area, providing options tailored to the region’s four-season climate. Whether you’re dealing with storm damage or aging shingles, our team helps you make the right investment in your home.

Why Choose Legacy Custom Contracting for Roof Replacement?

As a family-owned, local home improvement company, Legacy Custom Contracting has been trusted by homeowners throughout the Finger Lakes for decades. We bring craftsmanship, transparency, and a long-term mindset to every job.

• Local experience in Finger Lakes communities

• Certified crews

• Partnered with trusted brands like IKO and Owens Corning

• Fully insured and easy to reach throughout your project

We believe you should feel confident in your choice and supported for years to come.

Roofing Options Designed for NY Weather

From icy winters to humid summers, the Finger Lakes region puts your roof to the test. We help you choose materials that work hard year-round.

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt is a popular option for homeowners throughout Ontario and Monroe counties.

• Affordable, low-maintenance, and easy to repair

• Complements colonial, farmhouse, and other NY home styles

• Available in high-wind and impact-rated options

We only install shingles rated to handle upstate New York’s seasonal extremes.

Metal Roofing

Metal roofs are becoming increasingly popular among long-term homeowners seeking durability.

• Withstands snow, ice, and high winds

• Sheds water and snow quickly to reduce ice dam risk

• Energy efficient and often made from recycled materials

• Available in standing seam and corrugated profiles

We source products that are ENERGY STAR-rated and appropriate for residential use.

Choosing the Right Material for Your Home

We’re not here to upsell—we’re here to guide. Legacy Custom Contracting will help you compare your options based on your home’s structure, roof pitch, insulation needs, and long-term plans. Our team provides custom recommendations, not one-size-fits-all packages.

Is Metal Roofing Okay for Snowy Climates?

Yes, and that’s why it’s an increasingly popular choice in the Finger Lakes. Metal roofing offers several advantages in snowy or icy conditions:

• Snow slides off naturally, preventing heavy buildup and ice dams

• Durability: Unlike asphalt shingles, metal doesn’t crack or lose granules over time

• Lower maintenance: Fewer seams mean fewer leak risks, especially on complex rooflines

• Energy savings: Reflective coatings help reduce attic heat in summer and stabilize indoor temperatures in winter

However, metal isn't right for every home or budget. Our team will help you evaluate how it performs on your slope, structure, and ventilation setup, and we’ll be honest if it’s not the best fit.